What Stinks in LotRO: Looking for Fellowship Thoughts

Tony posted this on July 15th, 2009. It has 6 Comments »
Categorized as Editorials and Thoughts, What Stinks in LotRO.
Tagged as , , .
Shorthand Link: http://mmeow.net/tw1940

Update: I mis­tak­enly titled this Kin­ship instead of Fel­low­ship orig­i­nally. My apologies.

Peo­ple often com­plain about the Look­ing for Fel­low­ship (Group in other games) sys­tem in LotRO. It cer­tainly has improved from its orig­i­nal incar­na­tion and it’s cer­tainly not awful, but I think it’s safe to say that many peo­ple feel that there’s more to do before it’s truly use­ful. Frankly, I gen­er­ally find myself for­get­ting that it’s there in the first place.

The funny thing is that Tur­bine itself has already devel­oped a suc­cess­ful and smart Look­ing for Group (or “LFG”) sys­tem for Dun­geons and Drag­ons Online (aka “DDO”). I often see this cited by var­i­ous LotRO play­ers. If you fre­quent the forums, it’s likely you have as well.

Even so, I’m unsure how many other peo­ple out there are famil­iar with how DDO han­dles LFG needs. I thought it would be good to cover that a bit here.

Read the rest of this entry »

Turbine Comments on Applying DDO’s New Model to LotRO

Tony posted this on June 10th, 2009. It has 1 Comment »
Categorized as News.
Tagged as , , , .
Shorthand Link: http://mmeow.net/tw1868

Mas­sively has an inter­est­ing inter­view up with Tur­bine con­cern­ing Dun­geons and Drag­ons Online’s sub­scrip­tion model changes.

There’s a ques­tion posed by Mas­sively as to whether or not we can expect sim­i­lar changes to LotRO or even Asheron’s Call. Adam Mer­sky, Turbine’s Direc­tor of Com­mu­ni­ca­tion, was the one to answer this spe­cific ques­tion. I’ve under­lined cer­tain por­tions for emphasis.

Are there any plans to imple­ment this busi­ness model for LotRO or Asheron’s Call?

Adam: Not really. In bring­ing LotRO and DDO over to Asia over the past few years, the games we were com­pet­ing against over there were free-to-play games. So we saw the power of this model, know­ing that we needed to lead in this space, and we won­dered how we could do that. Do we port an exist­ing game? Do we make a new game? Then we looked at DDO and thought this game is pretty per­fect for this model. The style of game­play, with small group instanced expe­ri­ences, makes it easy for us to lock off and allow play­ers to pur­chase access as they need it. Where as LotRO is a much dif­fer­ent, open world with a tra­di­tional expe­ri­ence that doesn’t lend itself to this type of model.

And if you really go back to it, the way D&D was mar­keted in the 70s and 80s and even today, it was very much a micro­trans­ac­tion busi­ness, if you can do that in an offline busi­ness. But you had adven­tures that you played with your bud­dies and when you were ready for more, you headed down to the hobby store and bought more books, or you enhanced your expe­ri­ence with some­thing like new dice or minis or stuff like that. Lit­tle did we know when we started down this path awhile ago that right under our nose we had this game that was per­fect to start migrat­ing. We’ve been work­ing on this for well over a year, and we had to really go back and re-engineer the game to work under this model, but to answer your ques­tion, we have no plans to do this to LotRO because it’s a dif­fer­ent kind of game. Quite frankly, LotRO’s doing really well in its cur­rent situation.

This was my take on the sit­u­a­tion yes­ter­day, but it’s always nice to hear some­thing from a Tur­bine employee. It’ll be inter­est­ing to see how this plays out .… I would have really liked to see such things hap­pen to other titles such as Tab­ula Rasa (which never really won me over, but did have promise that could have been exploited by a sub­scrip­tion model like this), but clearly a lot went into this change. I sup­pose not every pub­lisher and/or devel­oper would find it to be worth­while.

DDO Goes Hybrid

Tony posted this on June 9th, 2009. It has 2 Comments »
Categorized as News.
Tagged as , , , .
Shorthand Link: http://mmeow.net/tw1865

A while back, we reported that Tur­bine was look­ing to hire a man­ager for micro­trans­ac­tions. A lot of us won­dered what this meant. Would exist­ing games be affected? Would this only affect upcom­ing titles? Most impor­tantly for us, what is the effect on LotRO?

I sup­pose we still don’t know the full answer to that last ques­tion, although Tur­bine has said they have no cur­rent plans for that.

The first two have been answered today with the announce­ment of Dun­geons and Drag­ons mov­ing over to a hybrid model. The game will offer both paid and free accounts. Paid accounts get addi­tional fea­tures (and 500 Tur­bine Points to spend on items), while free accounts are more lim­ited. The sys­tem is now in its beta stages and can be signed up for here. I’ve pasted in some basic notes for you:

  • Free means Free! – Players down­load and play DDO Unlim­ited for free by vis­it­ing www​.ddo​.com and within min­utes can be explor­ing a rich, beau­ti­ful and dan­ger­ous online world crawl­ing with leg­endary mon­sters, glo­ri­ous trea­sures, devi­ous traps, mind-bending puz­zles and end­less adven­tures from the world’s best known RPG. There is no time limit or level cap on free play.
  • Visit the new DDO Store!  — The DDO Store is loaded with hun­dreds of con­ve­nience items as well as pre­mium dun­geon packs, addi­tional char­ac­ter slots, hirelings (hired mus­cle), potions, char­ac­ter cus­tomiza­tion and more! The DDO Store is seam­lessly inte­grated into the game play and lets the player iden­tify new and excit­ing ways to enhance and cus­tomize their experience.
  • Be a DDO VIP! – Players who elect to sub­scribe to DDO Unlim­ited will have unlim­ited access to every pre­mium adven­ture pack, receive pri­or­ity server access, 10 char­ac­ter slots, a shared bank slot, and a monthly allot­ment of 500 Tur­bine Points to spend in the new DDO Store.

Obvi­ously this isn’t totally LotRO related, but I think it is an impor­tant announce­ment. I can see some peo­ple feel­ing that this makes real money trans­ac­tions less likely in LotRO and oth­ers feel­ing it makes them more likely. I think the thing that’s impor­tant to remem­ber here is that DDO has been sig­nif­i­cantly less suc­cess­ful than LotRO and has sig­nif­i­cantly less servers. I think this allows Tur­bine to pump some new blood into the title, which com­pa­ra­bly speak­ing is some­thing LotRO doesn’t need.

All I know is that I’ll be play­ing free DDO when it’s com­monly avail­able. :-o