MMeOw is currently down for the count, but please visit the LOTRO Combo Blog. It aggregates content from some of the best LOTRO-related blogs and podcasts on the net.

Putting the ‘RP’ back into ‘MMORPG’

Chris posted this on April 3rd, 2009.
Tagged as , , .
Categorized as Editorials and Thoughts, Why LotRO?.
Shorthand Link: http://mmeow.net/tw1413

Concert at the Pony

Wul­fare leaned back in his chair, peer­ing out from under his hood to observe the crowds packed into The Pranc­ing Pony. It amazed even him, a reg­u­lar patron, how a local event could sum­mon so many towns­folk to one
place for dis­cus­sion and col­lec­tive condolence.

He was not from the lands sur­round­ing Bree-Town. Indeed his mus­cu­lar frame, con­fi­dent pose and fairer skin betrayed his iden­tity as a well trav­elled adven­turer from the plains of Rohan. How­ever, despite this he could not help but feel a sense of duty to help out these folk when he over­heard snip­pets of
con­ver­sa­tion about press­ing matters.

“A word in yer ear stranger.” A grav­elly voice mur­mured from across the table at which Wul­fare was sat. “Word on the street ‘as it that last night was only the first strike. Some mad­man out­side is ravin’ about two bits of a key, down in that…tha-”,

“Great Bar­row.” Wul­fare inter­rupted, a wry grin on his face. “Leave it to me.”

Does this sound famil­iar? Per­haps it reminds you of a pas­sage from a novel you may have read, or a piece of lore pro­vided by the in-game quests and NPC chat­ter. Well this is in fact just one exam­ple of how Role Play­ing can begin
in Lord of the Rings Online. My first ever (and cur­rently only suc­cess­ful) group to Great Bar­row, the game’s first dun­geon, began when my Cap­tain Wul­fare was approached by some­one in Bree. They had four guildies ready for
GB and only needed a healer and ran­dom to get going. It just so hap­pened that my girl­friend (who plays a Min­strel called Esyllt) and I were also look­ing for a group to the dun­geon and we teamed up.

The funny thing was…the whole thing was done in char­ac­ter. Well…mostly. The other four were all part of the same role play­ing kin­ship and all were very help­ful and expe­ri­enced. There was no walk­ing involved, or tak­ing an
“RP break” after every fight to con­tem­plate the nature of the uni­verse etc. We tore through the place with only a bit of trou­ble with the Ter­ri­ble Twins, all out of char­ac­ter chat (and there was a lot of it) kept to the fel­low­ship chan­nel and no prob­lems in gen­eral. After­ward we mapped back to The Pranc­ing Pony, a sort of hub for role play on our server. We had a few drinks, some music, and then went our sep­a­rate ways.

At the time Esyllt and I were both brand new to the server and to the game itself. These role play­ers were in no way hard­core. They didn’t kick us, or even men­tion it after a slip of the tongue in /s (yes, it was a pro­fan­ity). The whole expe­ri­ence served as a gen­tle and extremely immers­ing intro­duc­tion to the mechan­ics of group­ing in the game, amongst other things.

Now RP is often seen in a neg­a­tive light by many in the MMO com­mu­nity. Some see it as a load of ‘thees’ and ‘thous’, an activ­ity that gets noth­ing done, involves copi­ous amounts of walk­ing, and makes you feel like a geek. I’m here to tell you that this is…well not entirely false, but…well…mostly. Whilst there are some hard­core role play­ers who do feel
it nec­es­sary to force their ideas of what is ‘proper’ on every­one and give RP a bad name, most are just nor­mal play­ers who want to play the game. If they can do that by con­nect­ing and empathis­ing with their avatars at the same time then so be it. If not, and it is often the way that you can’t find RP even on an RP ded­i­cated sever, they just carry on play­ing no harm no foul.

Lotro is a fan­tas­tic game for RP for sev­eral rea­sons. I will be writ­ing about them in depth in future arti­cles but for now I will high­light some in bul­let point form:

  • Tolkien’s world, char­ac­ters and lore are so deep and multi faceted that an MMO based within and around them is a per­fect oppor­tu­nity to explore avenues the nov­els did not.
  • Tur­bine very kindly included OOC (out of char­ac­ter) chan­nels in the game, as well as a Role Play­ing Flag (/rp on) that adds ‘Role­play­ing’ to your character’s tool tip for every­one to see. This allows role play­ers, and even the many who don’t but are inter­ested in it, to see who to inter­act with if they want a lit­tle bit of /s and /emote banter.
  • Lotro’s com­mu­nity is the best I have ever had the plea­sure of play­ing with in any game, MMO or not. The game seems to attract a very mature, fun lov­ing and open minded crowd who are both great at the game and at com­mu­ni­cat­ing too.
  • The Epic Quest Line in par­tic­u­lar, and many of the other quests, are engross­ing and sur­pris­ingly well writ­ten. This con­nec­tion with what hap­pens in the game world makes you feel more like a hero who makes a dif­fer­ence in
    Mid­dle Earth, rather than just some ran­dom toon you rolled to farm and grind your evenings away.

These are just a few exam­ples of why and how role play blos­soms in Lotro. Oth­ers, such as titles, houses, cos­tumes, sur­names, themed kin­ships and events add even more icing to this deli­cious cake. The game suc­ceeds on so many lev­els for casual play­ers like myself as well as those who want to explore and com­plete every­thing. There’s a place for every­one, and role play­ers are no exception.

The great­est appeal for me is the solid game play and vari­ety of deep fea­tures that don’t involve right click­ing a mob and doing the ‘one two, a one two three!’ dance. Role Play­ing is a hobby I have always been into and it is a plea­sure to bring it to Lotro with me. But it remains just that…a hobby. It’s fun and reward­ing but never con­sumes the game play expe­ri­ence for me.

I hope you’ve enjoyed this overview of RP in Mid­dle Earth. It is an hon­our to be given the chance to write with Tony for this great blog and I hope that my posts remain as con­sis­tent and as inter­est­ing as his. In future I will be writ­ing more about role play in the game as well as expe­ri­ences I have had as a Euro­pean player and other assorted top­ics. I play a few dif­fer­ent char­ac­ters on the only RP Eng­lish Code­mas­ters server, Lau­re­lin, and would be happy to answer any ques­tions or requests peo­ple might have. Enjoy!

Related posts

6 Responses to 'Putting the ‘RP’ back into ‘MMORPG’'

  1. […] Orig­i­nally posted here: Putting the ‘RP’ back into ‘MMORPG’ […]

    Like or Dis­like: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  2. mbp says:

    Hello , Chris I pre­sume, nice post and nice to hear from you.
    I have always been intrigued by RP although I sus­pect I wouldn’t have the patience to keep it up for long. There was an RP “bar” I used to hang out in EVE but the con­ver­sa­tion gen­er­ally flagged after a few min­utes as folk ran out of stuff to say. I have a ques­tion — how do you han­dle the con­flict between game pro­gres­sion and role playing?

    Like or Dis­like: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  3. Chris says:

    Heya and you pre­sume cor­rectly my friend.

    Hmm, that is a good ques­tion and one that dif­fer­ent peo­ple will take dif­fer­ent stand­points on. In my mind it requires both an open mind (when it comes to ene­mies you’ve defeated still being alive when you, say, help a lower level out on a Book quest) and for you to realise that some­times you can­not have both.

    For me, role play is a casual side of the game and so I do not mind so much putting it to the side­line when peo­ple want progress. How­ever, at the same time I would never sac­ri­fice one for the other.

    I am fairly new to Lotro but was the leader of a large(ish) rp guild in World of War­craft which even­tu­ally did some of the endgame con­tent. Basi­cally we set aside cer­tain days for rp meetings/dungeon runs, and oth­ers for seri­ous attempts at raids. There would be no OOC in the /s chan­nels but not really any IC either…everything was dis­cussed in vent or in /raid chat. If any­one wanted to start up an rp sto­ry­line they could, but it is impor­tant to know the dif­fer­ence between rp and pro­gress­ing with content.

    I hope this answered your ques­tion in a ridicu­lously inflated way! I’m look­ing to find the same bal­ance of rp/lore and game­play in Lotro when I get to higher lev­els, since this game is FAR more engross­ing and loyal to its canon than WoW ever was.

    Like or Dis­like: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  4. mbp says:

    I guess that makes sense Chris. I under­stand that some peo­ple aban­don pro­gres­sion altogther for RP (rumour has it there are a cou­ple of buxom bar­maids in the pony…) but I guess if you want to progress to slay­ing Balrog’s you need to make some con­ces­sion to game mechanics.

    I am still intrigues that you can do nor­mal dun­geon runs in RP though. Does this extend to the chat dur­ing combat?

    Like or Dis­like: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  5. Chris says:

    *Grin* Some­times it does, I guess it depends how com­fort­able an indi­vid­ual is with the encounter. I know when I play my Min­strel I often either macro rp say­ings to say some­times (although not so much I annoy every­one) or get time to type a lit­tle ditty dur­ing a bat­tle. But over­all com­bat chat is sit­u­ated in the party chan­nel where ooc is both needed and welcome.

    As for the barmaids…yes, yes there are. And it was only one time I tell ya!

    Like or Dis­like: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  6. Esyllt says:

    Bar­maid? What bar­maid? <advances on Chris, hoist­ing her Minstrel’s Friend] You didn’t tell –me– about any barmaid.

    Like or Dis­like: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

Leave a Reply




Allowed Tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>


Note: This post is over a year old. You may want to check later in this blog to see if there is new information relevant to your comment.